SEARCH
Pick Your Sport
Pick Your Sport
Pick Your Sport
Whether you're looking for baseball, football, basketball, hockey, soccer, wrestling or non-sport cards, we have a huge selection of sports trading cards to choose from.
Pick Your Years
Pick Your Sport
Pick Your Sport
Pick your decade to see the cards we have available that you can purchase.
Need Supplies?
Pick Your Sport
Everything Else
Do you need supplies to care for your cards? We have everything you need to protect your investment.
Everything Else
Pick Your Sport
Everything Else
Autographed jerseys, pictures, balls, bats, boxing gloves are just a small part of what we carry. Nascar, Starting Lineups and much more memorabilia available.
Why Choose Niagara Sports Cards
Grading Your Cards
Grading Your Cards
Grading Your Cards
At Niagara Sports Cards, we will submit your cards into PSA for them to grade. We will make sure that your cards are gradable so that you receive the highest grade number possible.
Grading Your Cards
Grading Your Cards
Grading Your Cards
At Niagara Sports Cards, we will submit your cards into Beckett for them to grade. We will make sure that your cards are gradable so that you receive the highest grade number possible.
Wide Selection
Grading Your Cards
We Buy Vintage!
We are a Topps Direct Dealer promising that we will have the products Topps produces in stock for all sports and non-sports. We offer one of the widest selections of collectibles in the WNY area, from rare cards and sets, to autograph pictures, jerseys and memorabilia. Our inventory is constantly updated to ensure that we have something for everyone.
We Buy Vintage!
Check Out Our ebay Store
We Buy Vintage!
We are here to help you determine the value and authenticity of your collectibles. We buy cards pre-1980, but will also look at your collections for possible purchase.
Check Out Our ebay Store
Check Out Our ebay Store
Check Out Our ebay Store
Our ebay store has hundreds of items that may not be included on our website. Be sure to check it out!
What's Happening
Check Out Our ebay Store
Check Out Our ebay Store
Follow us on our Facebook, X, Instagram & YouTube pages to check out what we're doing, what's new and what's coming up. Go to the : CONNECT WITH US section below this panel to go to our sites.
Sidewalk Sale w/ Denny McLain
We're having a sidewalk sale! We're overstocked and need to lighten the load! It will be September 15-17. We are also having Special Guest, former MLB pitcher and last 30 game winner Denny Mclain at the store for the 3 days signing autographs and telling stories of his time in the Majors. Don't want to miss the Bills game on TV on Sunday, no problem. We'll have the TV on to the game so you won't miss a single play! Come join us and pick up a great deal on the sports stuff you can't live without!